{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three consecutive years, the average home in the United States consistently sold for more than its price one year prior, but that trend has recently come to an end. Data for October indicates that the median home price has dipped slightly below last year's figures, marking the first yearly decrease since the spring of 2023. Concurrently, inventory levels have surged to the highest since early 2020, pending sales have dropped to a level not witnessed in over a decade, except during the initial pandemic phase, and roughly one in five homes on the market has received a price reduction.

The flip side of this is the increase in borrowing costs. The prevailing average for a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% range recently, following a brief period of improvement. While this gives buyers more negotiating power, many households still find monthly payments challenging.

This unique scenario presents an opportunity. With diminished offers and extended days on the market, sellers are becoming more amenable to discussions. The original list price and conditions are now often just a starting point. If you are in the market for a home this winter, consider what negotiations might be feasible, and how to approach them with your agent and lender.

Understanding the significance of a minor price decline

A national downturn of less than 0.5% is not indicative of a market crash, nor does it imply that prices are declining uniformly. Certain high-end coastal areas are still experiencing strong price growth despite limited inventory, while many significant metropolitan regions in the South and West have seen prices drop several percentage points compared to last year. Local market dynamics play a much more crucial role than the national average suggests.

The broader national trends indicate a shift in bargaining power. When homes languish on the market and more listings contend for fewer interested buyers, sellers tend to be more open to negotiations. This openness can manifest in the sale price, but equally in the terms of sale.

Looking beyond just the price

Many buyers fixate on the listed price, but in a high-interest-rate climate, the monthly payment and necessary funds at closing may be even more critical. A slight price reduction only marginally diminishes your loan, while applying that savings differently could better serve your budget. As buyers navigate a slower market, they often consider these negotiation points:

  • A purchase price lower than the original asking price
  • A credit from the seller to help with closing costs
  • Completion of repairs before finalizing the sale or a credit in lieu of repairs
  • Seller assistance to buy down your mortgage interest rate
  • A closing date or timeline that aligns with your move
  • Inclusion of items like appliances or window coverings with the property

Your representative is well-versed in how local sellers are reacting and can help you prioritize which items to request in your proposal. The objective is to not overwhelm with requests but rather to focus on what will maximize your benefit.

Managing closing costs with seller credits

Closing expenses usually amount to several percentage points of the loan value, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, securing the cash necessary for these costs can be the most challenging part of the acquisition process. A seller credit can alleviate some of those expenses, thereby reducing the amount of cash you need to close the deal.

Be aware that there are limits. Depending on the type of loan and the down payment size, programs often restrict how much a seller can contribute, typically ranging from 3% to 9% of the sale price, and usually, a credit cannot exceed your actual closing costs. It's wise to consult your lender early on to understand your options so that any request in your offer aligns with those guidelines.

Understanding rate buydowns

With mortgage rates exceeding 7% once again, one advantageous offering from sellers may be assistance with your interest rate. There are two primary types of buydowns to consider.

A permanent buydown allows you to pay discount points at closing to secure a lower rate for the entirety of your loan. Each point has a cost of 1% of the loan amount, and the reduction it provides varies by lender and market conditions. If you plan on maintaining the loan long-term, a permanent buydown could result in savings.

A temporary buydown, on the other hand, reduces your payment for the first one or two years. In a typical setup, the rate is lowered by two percentage points in the first year and by one percentage point in the second, stabilizing at the full rate afterward. For example, on a $350,000 30-year loan at about 7.34%, the monthly principal and interest would be approximately $2,409. With a temporary buydown, the first-year payment could drop to about $1,952 and the second year's around $2,176, before returning to the total amount in the third year. This arrangement may cost the seller a little over $8,000, which they might prefer to provide instead of lowering the price by a similar amount.

However, be mindful that a temporary buydown is not a permanent solution. You must be prepared for the original payment once the discount period concludes, and lenders generally qualify borrowers based on the full interest rate. Although you might consider refinancing if rates decrease in the future, it's uncertain when or if that opportunity will arise.

Don't forego inspections in a competitive market

In more frantic markets, many buyers opted to waive inspections or restrict their requests to enhance their chances in bidding wars. In a more measured market, there is less urgency to relinquish those protective measures. A comprehensive home inspection can provide insight into the state of the roof, heating and cooling systems, plumbing, electrical setups, and foundation prior to making any commitments.

Should the inspection reveal issues, your agent can assist you in determining the best course of action, whether to request repairs, negotiate a price reduction, or seek a credit. Often, credits can be more straightforward than requesting repairs from the seller, as you can choose how and when the work is done, though the right approach will depend on the specific problems encountered and your loan's stipulations.

Prepare your financing first

Even the best negotiation tactics are ineffective without solid financing backing you. When presented with two offers, sellers are likely to lean towards the buyer who appears most capable of closing. Prior to actively searching for a home, obtaining a full preapproval instead of a cursory prequalification is crucial. Understand your maximum comfortable monthly payment rather than only focusing on the loan ceiling, and compare offers from multiple lenders. Inquire with each lender regarding their policies on seller credits or buydowns to avoid unexpected issues.

Key questions to review with your agent

  • What is the typical time on the market for homes in this area, and how frequently do prices get adjusted?
  • Which is likely to assist my budget more: a price reduction, a closing cost credit, or a rate buydown?
  • How do the specific condition and history of this home impact my requests?
  • What contingencies should I maintain in my proposal for my protection?

Final thoughts

The current market's softness does not equate to cheap buying, especially with the rise in mortgage rates. Nevertheless, for those prepared, it allows for more negotiation room to craft a deal that is financially fit. Armed with robust financing, a clear understanding of your priorities, and support from your agent and lender, you could secure terms that were previously unimaginable just a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Send Us a Message